Some breastfed babies have a hard time accepting the bottle. So you have to find one that meets their needs. If you are looking for the best bottle for a breastfed baby who refuses the bottle, then you must consider the Mimijumi vs. Comotomo bottles.
Mimijumi and Comotomo bottles are rated relatively high by parents due to their ability to mimic the breastfeeding experience.
The two bottles share similar features from the material of the nipple to their size and feel, which make them appear very similar to the mother’s breasts. For this reason, it can difficult to decide which one to get between the two.
However, they have some slight differences, which is why some babies may prefer one brand over the other.
This review will help you understand these differences and similarities so that you can decide which bottle to get between Mimijumi and Comotomo to help your baby accept the bottle.
Mimijumi vs. Comotomo Bottle Quick Comparison
Key product features
Mimijumi bottle made from high-quality Swiss nylon. Thus, it is much firmer than pure silicone bottles. Despite being tight, the nylon makes the bottles strong in that they do not break easily; hence they are as durable as the plastic bottles.
The nylon also gives the bottle a clear glass-like appearance so that you might think of them from a glass.
The nipple is from medical grade silicone. This gives it a texture that is soft and smooth, like the natural mother’s breasts. Hence, babies can hardly differentiate between feeding from these bottles and natural breasts.
The natural feeling prevents nipple confusion, which is a significant problem that parents face when they introduce their babies to bottles.
No harmful chemicals
A while ago, most liquid and food containers, including baby bottles, were lined with a chemical known as bisphenol A (BPA).
Concerns arose regarding its potentially harmful effects on humans, especially in babies. As a result, the FDA banned the use of BPA in food containers, particularly in containers like bottles and sippy cups.
However, some manufacturers still attempt to use BPA in plastic containers. That is why you must make sure any product you buy for your baby is BPA free.
This bottle does not contain any harmful chemicals, so it is very safe for babies. It is BPA free, BPS free, latex and lead-free, phthalates free, and does not contain any known Estrogenic Activity (EA) agents.
Leak-proof nipple (Non-free flow mechanism)
If you take a Mimijumi bottle with any liquid and hold it upside down, not even a drop will leak.
The innovative non-free flow mechanism at the nipple prevents any liquid from flowing out. Milk comes out only when a baby sucks on the nipple.
This mechanism also helps the baby to control the flow of milk because when he or she stops sucking, the milk stops flowing out, and if he sucks slowly, the milk flows gradually.
Thus, this is an excellent innovative design, which also makes Mimijumi a suitable bottle for traveling.
Few very brands of baby bottles have a non-skid base, and Mimijumi is one of them. Most bottles will topple over even with the slightest knock, but these bottles remain stable on the table or countertop.
This means that you will be able to fill the bottle without sliding all over the kitchen counter while you hold a wiggly baby on the other arm.
This brand of baby bottles comes in two different sizes; Very Hungry and Not So Hungry bottles.
The Very Hungry bottles are more massive, 8 ounces, and can hold up to 240 ml of milk.
The Not So Hungry bottles are smaller, 4 ounces, and hold about 120ml of milk.
You can choose to buy each bottle separately or get a Mimijumi starter set, which has two bottles.
Unlike the Comotomo, the neck of the Mimijumi bottles is slightly angled/tilted. The neck is turned so that even when the bottle is inverted during feeding, the nipple remains horizontal and at a right angle, allowed the baby to latch correctly, just like in breastfeeding.
It helps the baby to grasp during feeding, which provides a natural experience of breastfeeding.
Also, the titled neck allows the proper upright position of the baby during feeding.
When a baby swallows too much air during feeding, they become gassy, colicky, and fussy.
This is why the Mimijumi bottle has an anti-colic venting system. The vent allows that air to enter and leave the bottle seamlessly without mixing with the milk or formula while the baby is feeding.
Besides, the non-free flow mechanism that helps babies to control the flow of milk also helps to minimize the amount of air swallowed during feeding.
The bottles have measurement markings that show the amount of liquid. They also come with a jar to help you in measuring accurate feedings.
Key Product Features
Comotomo bottles are made from medical grade silicone. The FDA approves medical-grade silicone as a safe material for making food and drinks containers like baby bottles, plates, and sippy cups.
Silicone makes these bottles soft, squeezable and gives them a skin-like texture. This, coupled with the natural breast shape of the bottle, helps to prevent nipple confusion. Thus, it is easier for nursing moms to switch from breastfeeding to bottle and vice versa.
The only challenge with medical-grade silicone is that it makes Comotomo bottles difficult to warm since silicone is heat resistant. If you are having a difficult time warming these bottles, this bottle warmer works great.
Related article: A detailed guide on warming Comotomo bottles
No harmful chemicals
Just like the Mimijumi bottles, Comotomo bottles do not contain any chemical that can pose a risk to your baby’s health.
They are BPA free and do not contain phthalates and PVC.
As aforementioned, the nipples are from silicone. So they are soft, flexible, and 100% safe.
They are available in different flow levels, which you buy separately depending on your baby’s age. There is a slow flow nipple that has one hole that is suitable for a newborn aged 0-3 months. The medium flow nipple has two holes, and it is appropriate for babies aged 3-6 months.
The third type of nipple has three holes for the fast flow of milk, which is suitable for babies aged six months and above. There is a fourth nipple type known as variable flow, which is Y shaped. This is designed for babies six months and older who are starting to take thicker fluids.
Just like the Mimijumi, when you hold the Comotomo bottle with milk upside down, it will not leak. This is because it has a leak-proof mechanism that allows milk to flow only when the baby is sucking.
The neck of these bottles is wide to allow easy cleaning without the need for a bottle brush.
The wide neck also supports the wide mound, which is shaped like a natural breast.
Comotomo bottles have two anti-colic vents, unlike Mimijumi, which has only one. This means that they are more efficient at expelling air from the baby during feeding.
Thus, when compared to the Mimijumi bottle, Comotomo bottles are the best for preventing colic and gas in babies.
These bottles come in two sizes as well; 5 ounces and 8 ounces. The 5-ounce bottles come with a slow flow nipple while the 8-ounce bottle comes with a medium flow. You can, however, purchase replacement nipples depending on the needs of your baby. For instance, you can get the variable flow nipple if your baby starts taking thicker fluids.
There are volume markings on the side of the bottle that have a different texture from the rest of the bottle. The markings are in fluid ounces (oz.) and milliliters (ml).
Mimijumi vs. Comotomo bottles overall performance
Ease of use
Mimijumi bottles are straightforward to use. When you are holding a hungry-crying baby, you can easily open and close this bottle with hand. The non-skid base allows the bottle to stand firm on a tabletop as you replace the nipple, add the milk or prepare the formula without the bottle toppling over.
However, the travel cap on this bottle is challenging to put on. It does not stay in place, which becomes an inconvenience when traveling.
Comotomo bottles are relatively easy to use. However, they are a bit difficult to open with one hand. They also do not have a non-skid base, so they can topple over quickly if you are not using both hands.
Since the Comotomo bottles have a wide-neck and not angled like the Mimijumi bottles, they are easy to clean. You do not even need to use a bottle brush since your hand can easily fit into them.
Moreover, Comotomo bottles are heat resistant. So, they can be washed in hot soapy water or a dishwasher and sterilized in a microwave by boiling or using a sterilizer.
Similarly, Mimijumi bottles also do not need a bottle brush to reach all the corners of the bottle when cleaning. This is because despite being angled, they are wide enough to fit your arm when washing. Moreover, they have fewer parts; hence, you will not take too much time cleaning or setting up.
The baby controls milk flow in both Comotomo and Mimijumi bottles. Both have different milk flow nipples, which you can get based on your baby’s needs.
However, for the Mimijumi bottle, some parents have found the nipple to be too long and hard for a newborn baby to use.
Also, even with the slow flow nipple, some parents have argued that the milk let down is too fast, especially for a newborn.
The Comotomo bottle is lightly textured to enable the baby to hold it without slipping. So it is elementary to grip. Similarly, the Mimijumi bottle is firm and makes it easy for the baby to grab.
From this review, it is clear that both bottles are very similar. For instance, they both have a silicone nipple and a mound that is shaped like a breast. Thus, they mimic the natural breast, which helps to prevent nipple confusion. This means that they are also the best bottles for breastfed babies who refuse the bottle.
The two bottles are also easy to clean, have a leak-proof mechanism, antic-colic vents, and different bottle and nipple sizes.
However, both bottles fit in selected bottle warmers due to their wide neck.
These bottles only have minor differences. For instance, the Comotomo bottle is soft and squeezable, while the Mimijumi bottle is firm and unsqueezable. If your baby loves to squeeze the breasts a bit when feeding, he or she might not be able to do this if feeding on the Mimijumi bottle. So he might notice the difference between your breasts and the bottle.